I'm helping out at work with an internal United Way campaign. I really haven't done print work in ages, but they wanted a superhero theme to show up on some printed flyers and posters and such, which makes me the default go-to guy. "Sounds like fun," I said, "Happy to help!"
The initial idea the project manager had was to have a superhero mascot for this campaign. Showcased through a series of comic strips over the course of a week with a "big reveal" at the end that the superhero's secret identity was in fact you, the reader. The final comic was to be a close-up head shot of the hero with a mirror over the face area. Kind of a "You can be a hero by donating to the United Way" message.
OK, cool. Not a bad idea. But it poses a distinct design challenge for the actual hero. It'd have to be fairly androgynous and devoid of any racial characteristics, so that the "You can be a hero" bit works regardless of who's looking at it.
So I sketched out some designs. One was a pretty obvious Iron Man rip-off. One was kind of a shadowy cloud character. The one the project manager and I ultimately liked best was...
The colors were chosen because they're official UW colors, but the design is modeled off the Invincible Man, a Jack Kirby design that I always really liked and think was/is sorely under-utilized. (A red cape was one of the design stipulations, since they're doing some photo pieces with employees wearing a red cape.)
The manager was really happy with it, and I started working up some of the materials for the project. But she called things to a quick halt last night because one of the higher ups finally got a look at it. He didn't like it at all. No, a hero should be decidedly male. With big muscles. And you need to see his face. Maybe just a domino mask or something. Short, dark hair. You know, a comic book superhero? Oh, and this total redesign obviously doesn't impact the schedule at all, so I have to have this approved and in several design pieces and off to the printer in less than a week. So the current version of our intrepid hero looks like...
I'll make no bones about it -- I traced Superman. Literally traced. This is pretty obviously what the head honcho was asking for anyway, and I don't have time to be clever with it. I don't have the time now to make sure the anatomy and perspective and whatever are correct. I'm going with getting the job done as fast as possible. If I'd happen to have a cleaner version available, I would've just removed the S shield in Photoshop and used that.
Now, setting aside that this totally wrecks the whole "could be you" angle for over half the people seeing it, I'm more concerned about the fact that the hero had to be a white male. It's not even an instance of a white male just drawing another white male because it's easiest to look in the mirror -- we're talking about being presented with an intentionally nondescript hero specifically for the purpose of being as inclusive as possible, and being told that's essentially wrong because superheroes are white men.
Granted, there are more white male superheroes out there than anything else, but to completely shut down the idea that someone other than a white male could be a superhero...? That that default is (supposedly) so well known that anything else is wrong? That the stereotype is so pervasive that no other options are even viable? I can't even begin to describe how frustrated and disheartened I am right now.
If he doesn't like my original design, that's fine. I'm okay with that. I'm not a character designer. If he doesn't like the illustration itself, I can totally see that. I create websites, not illustrations. I'd be fine if he wanted to critique the specifics of what I actually did; I'm used to that kind of thing. I'm receptive to criticism.
But to dismiss the entire idea of trying to being inclusive? To actively reject that superheroes can be something other than white men? I don't know the guy who said this personally, so I can't say if he's really sexist or racist or anything but, speaking as a white male, I will harbor absolutely no resentment if/when all the minorities rise up and beat the living shit out of all of us.
- ► 2015 (193)
- ► 2014 (259)
- ► 2013 (342)
- ► 2012 (372)
- ► 2011 (367)
- The 14th Dalai Lama Review
- A Curmudgeon's Take On Halloween
- The Daily News, Take 2
- Yet Another Detective 27 Up For Sale?!?
- The Adventures Of Unemployed Man Review
- Fist Stick Knife Gun Review
- Today's Adventures At B&N
- The Reconcilers Review
- These Kids Today Don't Know Their History!
- Comic Fandom: Don't Be Doing It Wrong
- My UW Comics
- Fummetti/Illustrated Comics?
- A Non-Partisan Political Rant Which Lightly Touche...
- Arrests Made In Comic Book Burglary Case
- Mad Friday Night Ramblings
- I'm Calling Mash-Ups On Account Of Sickness
- I Think You're Sauceome
- Happy Birthday, Jerk!
- The Power Of Branding
- Hatter M, Nature of Wonder Review
- Time For Some Self-Promotion
- The Hero Who Could Be You... As Long As You're A W...
- Arcana Who?
- Weighing In On This Comics Journalism Hoohah... Ag...
- Iconography For Kirby's Unfinished Sagas?
- Just In Time For Halloween
- Saturday Comics History Link-Blogging
- Paul Conrad: Drawing Fire
- ▼ October (29)
- ► 2009 (365)
- ► 2008 (358)
- ► 2007 (382)