Today, I'm just going with a collection of apparently-not-widely-viewed videos talking about newspaper comics...
I was thinking about comics for blind people today. Obviously, a traditional comic wouldn't really be readable for someone who couldn't actually see the pictures. I've heard of a few blind folks whose sense of touch is so acute that they can differentiate the inks raised up off a piece of paper, but I would think that all that the most simply drawn, single-color comics would be at all useable by even them. Most everything these days is so saturated with ink that no one would be able to distinguish one color from the next.
You could translate the text portions of a comic into braille, of course, but that would only work to a limited degree. Only about 10% of legally blind people in the U.S. can read braille, and that still doesn't count towards the illustrative component of comics. But what if there were a way to make comics a more tactile experience?
It turns out that Philipp Meyer did some thinking along these a couple years ago...
But, even though Meyer tested it with blind people, I'm sitting here wondering about it's effectiveness. Particularly, he's got panel borders drawn/raised in. It's so obvious as to almost seem not worth mentioning to you and me, who are familiar with comics construction. But what about someone who's NEVER seen a comic? As sighted people, we use them as a visual cue to separate one discrete scene from the next. But it's a visual cue. Does a blind person need that? Does it make sense in their context? I mean, I'm sure that the border can be felt and they can use it to recognize distinct boundaries of some kind, but does that translate into distinct and separate images as well? I'm not trying to be facetious here; I honestly don't know. How does a blind person read that panel border, and is there a more logical way to separate panels here tactilely?
Meyer has written up a pretty detailed overview/history of his project and I'd be curious to see if anyone else has followed up on this.
You could translate the text portions of a comic into braille, of course, but that would only work to a limited degree. Only about 10% of legally blind people in the U.S. can read braille, and that still doesn't count towards the illustrative component of comics. But what if there were a way to make comics a more tactile experience?
It turns out that Philipp Meyer did some thinking along these a couple years ago...
I wanted to make a medium [comics] accessible to more people...He developed a relatively simple 24-panel comic that could be rendered using the same techniques that are used to create braille. In Meyer's version, though, there is no text so there's no braille literacy required.It's an interesting idea, and one that seems to make sense from a sighted person's perspective.
It's not about the particular story I created but more about showing the potential of sequential-tactile-storytelling. Maybe this is just another way to tell stories or eventually it could even be helpful for educational purposes in explaining certain concepts.
But, even though Meyer tested it with blind people, I'm sitting here wondering about it's effectiveness. Particularly, he's got panel borders drawn/raised in. It's so obvious as to almost seem not worth mentioning to you and me, who are familiar with comics construction. But what about someone who's NEVER seen a comic? As sighted people, we use them as a visual cue to separate one discrete scene from the next. But it's a visual cue. Does a blind person need that? Does it make sense in their context? I mean, I'm sure that the border can be felt and they can use it to recognize distinct boundaries of some kind, but does that translate into distinct and separate images as well? I'm not trying to be facetious here; I honestly don't know. How does a blind person read that panel border, and is there a more logical way to separate panels here tactilely?
Meyer has written up a pretty detailed overview/history of his project and I'd be curious to see if anyone else has followed up on this.
- Maggie Thompson remembers her husband and one of comic fandom's founders, Don, who passed away twenty years ago.
- CAKE is this weekend. Lots of creators are debuting new works there. Caitlin McGurk will be interviewing Tony Millionaire. Lucy Knisley is accepting $20 commissions if you'll be at the show! For only being in its third year, it's looking to be a very impressive event! I'll be wandering around, too, in the highly unlikely event that you find no one better to talk to.
I came across an eBay auction for a scrapbook of Winsor McCay related clippings. Most of them are of course his cartoons (though Little Nemo does not seem to make an appearance) but the book also includes articles about him as well. This piece caught my eye...I've taken the liberty of re-typing the text of the piece itself...
Winsor McCay, famous cartoonist for the Hearst newspapers, paid a fleeting visit to San Francisco yesterday. He came to California especially to see the city. he said there were so many big buildings and houses that he couldn't see it and went on for a rest at the Hearst ranch in san Luis Obispo county.The copy isn't written very well, I don't think, but I get the impressions that McCay was visiting on a business related trip for Hearst. The note about not really seeing the city and dashing off some sketches specifically for the article suggest he was in the newspaper office itself. I'm not sure how much of this would've been consider just filler, and how much they were using to advertise/promote their own paper. In any event, it's an interesting snapshot of the cartoonist outside of what we typically see about him.
He will return later to look up the fable city of the Golden Gate which he suspects is hidden away somewhere beneath the chimney tops and among the brick walls.
McCay is the man who uses his pen to make men think. He also likes to make them smile. Among his famous characters of the comic page are Little Nemo in Slumberland, the Rarebit Fiend, Sammy Sneeze, Dull Care, Poor Jake, Hungry Henrietta and the Jungle Imps.
McCay is serious for a purpose in his powerful cartoons. "There are some things men have to be serious about if the world is going ahead," he says. If it were not for theat, he would be entertaining them all the time.
Professionally, McCay frequently thunders, but personally and socially he always smiles.
People sometimes are a little afraid of McCay's cartoons--they hit home so close and so hard. A puppy dog wouldn't be afraid of McCay himself. He is one hundred per cent human. That is why San Francisco will be sure to like him.
McCay did not set out to become a preacher, although his cartoons are the strongest kind of sermons. He made a number of sketches last night to illustrate the impressions some people get of his probably personal appearance. He does not favor these impressions. He says he never claimed that he was handsome, but considers himself better looking than any one expects him to be.
I don't pay much attention to DC these days. Most of what I see/hear comes across in a kind of osmosis-like fashion as I'm keeping up with comic book news in general. Nothing specifically against DC, but I just haven't really connected with much of what they were doing since about 1986. But lately, I've caught a couple pieces on how DC might not be doing as well as it should, and not really serving the (even small superhero niche) market as well as Marvel.
Since I'm not all up in DC's business, I'm not going to ponfiticate about they could solve all their problems by doing X, Y and Z. But I will point to what I think is a more significantly noticeable symptom of their broader issue. First, let's take a look at their home page at DCComics.com...
Attractive enough site, I suppose, but let's set asthetics aside. Where do you learn about comics here? You have to click on the "COMICS" link in the navigation. There's nothing about comics visible on their home page.
True, there's some new release information if you scroll down the page a bit, but on that's not, as we say in the trade, "above the fold." Which means that it's not going to be seen by many (most?) visitors because they're not going to bother to scroll to see it. (As an aside, the "above the fold" terminology is actually borrowed from the newspaper industry. No one actually expects you to fold your screen!)
Now, granted, it's entirely possible that I happened to catch this screen grab on the one day that there was no comics news taking up one of the top spots on the page. But that still misses the point. The point is that I've just landed on dcCOMICS.com and I have to select a separate category to actually get to the part that talks about comics. The URL for that section uncomfortably reads: dccomics.com/comics. Which is perfectly serviceable technologicially speaking, but it kind of doesn't make sense. Why would you need a comics section for a comics site?
And once you get into that section, you can read about the comics that are out now and coming out soon and whatever. But what if you, I don't know, wanted to actually BUY a comic? Well, then you have to scroll down a ways before you have the option to go over to another site, depending on how you want to buy your comics. If you want digital books, you go to readdcentertainment.com. If you want printed books, you have to go to http://www.shopdcentertainment.com/category/dcshop_brands/dc+comics.do?ref=DCBUYNOW and then select "Books" from the "Graphic Novels" menu. A menu which, I might, has "Books" as the only option in it. Lastly, if you want a subscription to the pamphlet comics, you can go to https://ssl.drgnetwork.com/ecom/dcc/app/live/dccmultisubs?org=dcc and select from 26 of their titles. None of these locations, you'll note, are actually on dccomics.com.
If you check out Marvel's site, they have the same basic set-up. The home page features more about their movies and shows than their comics, and you have to select "COMICS" to get to a page talking specifically about them. Then from there, you have options to go to a digital comics store, or get a print subscription. Although I don't see where you can buy printed graphic novels through their site, they do have a much larger number of titles available on a subscription basis. The big difference, though, is that regardless of which option you select, you're still on a Marvel.com domain: comicstore.marvel.com, subscriptions.marvel.com, shop.marvel.com.
And at no point does it sound like you're falling into a recursive linguistic loop. It's Marvel Dot Com Slash Comics, not DC Comics Dot Com Slash Comics. (Which is really, when you think about it, Detective Comics Comics Dot Com Slash Comics.)
You know, this all seems terribly superficial and it really is. But it's emblamatic of DC's overall approach, I think. They're not thinking strategically. Or at least not strategically enough for a company of their size with character licenses of their weight. Whatever you might think of his business practices or ethics, when Ronald Perelman bought Marvel in 1989, he called it a mini-Disney. And while there were some seriously bad moves made by the company in the immediate years afterward, I think that they collectively started to address the larger picture. Not just what's going on in the Marvel Universe (i.e. how the latest event crossover epic fits into each individual title) but how that works relative to movies, TV, toys, games, etc. It took them a solid ten years to get that figured out, but they got there.
DC, on the other hand, doesn't seem to ever have had that. (Not in recent memory anyway.) They had a fantastic ten-year run with Smallville and parlayed that into... a single comic book title that didn't even start until a year after the last show aired. They've had multiple well-received Teen Titans cartoons that they seemed to smack in the face with let's-just-call-them-radically-more-adult interpretations in the comics.
I get that the movie production studios aren't necessarily going to work hand-in-glove with the comics people, and that it's perfectly fine to have multiple interpretations of a character out in the public. But look at DC's website. It's a site that's essentially copying what other people (not necessarily just Marvel; they were just an easy counter-example) are doing without any strategy behind how/where/why that might or might not be a good idea. I get that same sense when I hear snippets about them trying to shoehorn a Superman/Batman movie together. I don't know what the solution is, but not only am I seeing evidence that neither does DC, what I'm seeing suggests that they don't even know that it's a problem that needs to be solved!
Since I'm not all up in DC's business, I'm not going to ponfiticate about they could solve all their problems by doing X, Y and Z. But I will point to what I think is a more significantly noticeable symptom of their broader issue. First, let's take a look at their home page at DCComics.com...
Attractive enough site, I suppose, but let's set asthetics aside. Where do you learn about comics here? You have to click on the "COMICS" link in the navigation. There's nothing about comics visible on their home page.
True, there's some new release information if you scroll down the page a bit, but on that's not, as we say in the trade, "above the fold." Which means that it's not going to be seen by many (most?) visitors because they're not going to bother to scroll to see it. (As an aside, the "above the fold" terminology is actually borrowed from the newspaper industry. No one actually expects you to fold your screen!)
Now, granted, it's entirely possible that I happened to catch this screen grab on the one day that there was no comics news taking up one of the top spots on the page. But that still misses the point. The point is that I've just landed on dcCOMICS.com and I have to select a separate category to actually get to the part that talks about comics. The URL for that section uncomfortably reads: dccomics.com/comics. Which is perfectly serviceable technologicially speaking, but it kind of doesn't make sense. Why would you need a comics section for a comics site?
And once you get into that section, you can read about the comics that are out now and coming out soon and whatever. But what if you, I don't know, wanted to actually BUY a comic? Well, then you have to scroll down a ways before you have the option to go over to another site, depending on how you want to buy your comics. If you want digital books, you go to readdcentertainment.com. If you want printed books, you have to go to http://www.shopdcentertainment.com/category/dcshop_brands/dc+comics.do?ref=DCBUYNOW and then select "Books" from the "Graphic Novels" menu. A menu which, I might, has "Books" as the only option in it. Lastly, if you want a subscription to the pamphlet comics, you can go to https://ssl.drgnetwork.com/ecom/dcc/app/live/dccmultisubs?org=dcc and select from 26 of their titles. None of these locations, you'll note, are actually on dccomics.com.
If you check out Marvel's site, they have the same basic set-up. The home page features more about their movies and shows than their comics, and you have to select "COMICS" to get to a page talking specifically about them. Then from there, you have options to go to a digital comics store, or get a print subscription. Although I don't see where you can buy printed graphic novels through their site, they do have a much larger number of titles available on a subscription basis. The big difference, though, is that regardless of which option you select, you're still on a Marvel.com domain: comicstore.marvel.com, subscriptions.marvel.com, shop.marvel.com.
And at no point does it sound like you're falling into a recursive linguistic loop. It's Marvel Dot Com Slash Comics, not DC Comics Dot Com Slash Comics. (Which is really, when you think about it, Detective Comics Comics Dot Com Slash Comics.)
You know, this all seems terribly superficial and it really is. But it's emblamatic of DC's overall approach, I think. They're not thinking strategically. Or at least not strategically enough for a company of their size with character licenses of their weight. Whatever you might think of his business practices or ethics, when Ronald Perelman bought Marvel in 1989, he called it a mini-Disney. And while there were some seriously bad moves made by the company in the immediate years afterward, I think that they collectively started to address the larger picture. Not just what's going on in the Marvel Universe (i.e. how the latest event crossover epic fits into each individual title) but how that works relative to movies, TV, toys, games, etc. It took them a solid ten years to get that figured out, but they got there.
DC, on the other hand, doesn't seem to ever have had that. (Not in recent memory anyway.) They had a fantastic ten-year run with Smallville and parlayed that into... a single comic book title that didn't even start until a year after the last show aired. They've had multiple well-received Teen Titans cartoons that they seemed to smack in the face with let's-just-call-them-radically-more-adult interpretations in the comics.
I get that the movie production studios aren't necessarily going to work hand-in-glove with the comics people, and that it's perfectly fine to have multiple interpretations of a character out in the public. But look at DC's website. It's a site that's essentially copying what other people (not necessarily just Marvel; they were just an easy counter-example) are doing without any strategy behind how/where/why that might or might not be a good idea. I get that same sense when I hear snippets about them trying to shoehorn a Superman/Batman movie together. I don't know what the solution is, but not only am I seeing evidence that neither does DC, what I'm seeing suggests that they don't even know that it's a problem that needs to be solved!
I normally want to take this space for newspaper comic strips, but A) I think this is really note-worthy and something I think deserves wider attention, and B) so far, I've only seen it addressed on one other site.
Do you recall the problems John Campbell had a few months back in fulfilling his pledges for the Sad Pictures for Children Kickstarter? Well, it was obviously way beyond problems with pledge fulfillment and led to much speculation and judging online. Fleen also ran the story there if you need to catch up. Be warned, it's really not pretty.
Fortunately, the new development I'm passing on today is something of positive turn to this story. Max "the guy who created Cards Against Humanity" Temkin posted this as a SPfC project update...
I don't have much else to add other than to say I hope Temkin's kindness helps Campbell and that, more broadly, Campbell gets the help he needs. I don't have any skin in this game, but I really hate to hear when creative individuals have issues like Campbell has evidently had.
Best of luck, John, and thanks very much, Max.
Do you recall the problems John Campbell had a few months back in fulfilling his pledges for the Sad Pictures for Children Kickstarter? Well, it was obviously way beyond problems with pledge fulfillment and led to much speculation and judging online. Fleen also ran the story there if you need to catch up. Be warned, it's really not pretty.
Fortunately, the new development I'm passing on today is something of positive turn to this story. Max "the guy who created Cards Against Humanity" Temkin posted this as a SPfC project update...
Hello! My name is Max Temkin. I’m a designer from Chicago.(He posted his contact information publicly on Kickstarter. I'm sure any spam he gets from having it duplicated on my site will be neglible. But, Max, if you want me to pull that part down, just let me know.)
I am a great fan of John Campbell’s work and a backer of Sad Pictures for Children, and it’s been really hard for me to see this amazing book create so much trouble for both John and its backers.
Over the last few months, I’ve been talking to John about helping to close out this project, and I’ve agreed to take over the project and fulfill the remaining books to backers. On Monday, I picked up the remaining 100 books from John’s apartment, and I’m going to work with you to distribute them fairly to people who haven’t gotten their project rewards yet.
In just a moment, you'll receive a backer-only update with a link to a form to fill out if you didn’t get your copy of Sad Pictures for Children. We’ll do this on the honor system; there are only 100 books left, so please only fill out the survey if you didn’t get yours.
To close out this project quickly, I’m going to pay out of pocket to deliver the remaining books. All I would ask of you in return is to continue to support John’s art in the future, and continue to take risks on Kickstarter to help make new art.
Thanks for your patience, and I look forward to getting the rest of these books out to you,
- Max
P.S. I will do my best to keep up with Kickstarter backer comments, but if you need to reach me quickly with any questions or comments, I am @MaxTemkin on Twitter, my email is max.temkin@gmail.com, you can text me at (312) 857-4184.
I don't have much else to add other than to say I hope Temkin's kindness helps Campbell and that, more broadly, Campbell gets the help he needs. I don't have any skin in this game, but I really hate to hear when creative individuals have issues like Campbell has evidently had.
Best of luck, John, and thanks very much, Max.
Back in high school, a friend of mine gifted to me a collection of a couple hundred comics. His older brother had just died, and he wanted to set aside that part of his life. That's how I came to read as many X-Men books as I have. I was never a big fan; the cast and continuity seemed impossibly convoluted even by then. In part because of that, New Mutants #45 stands out as it's a stand-alone story and easy to follow along regardless of how much/little you know about the X-universe.
The theme of the X-Men as a stand-in for racism and bigotry was well-trod by then. Looking back, it could be a bit ham-fisted at times, but for pre-teens and teenagers, you tend to need that lack of subtlety to get your message across. That New Mutants story was a little like that.
In the story, a student arrives at a new school and is taunted by all the popular kids. They call him "such a rat-faced, geeky little dweeb" that he must be a "mutie." Which stings more than it might because he was, in fact, a mutant. He's bullied more and, rather than continue to face the ongoing taunts, commits suicide.
The story ended with Kitty Pryde providing a eulogy...Reading that again now, I still get teary-eyed. It was an incredibly powerful statement for me to hear at that time in my life, and I carried that comic around like a totem for months. I read it over and over again, on seemingly every bus ride home from school after yet another day of insults and ostracization. This single comic is largely what got me through high school.
And this is me we're talking about here. White, gisgendered, heterosexual male. I have just about every social priveledge that one can be born with. By all rights, I shouldn't have needed this. I shouldn't have needed to be so deeply touched by the message in this comic. I shouldn't have needed to be told that those insults are nothing compared to what some people endure. I shouldn't have needed to be told that those insults were just labels meant to confine us to a small box.
I pulled this issue out for the first time in decades to write this post. I set the comic aside when I left for college, thinking that I would effectively be able to start over and leave all of that high school bullshit behind. And I've never cracked it since then for fear that it would be far inferior than the importance I put upon it would critically warrant. But I was struck by two things just now in re-reading this issue.
First, that last panel. I didn't consciously remember that as a critical part of the story or even a significant part of Kitty's speech. But I know that for a little over a decade now, I've actively eschewed labels of any kind. I can only find a published version of my declaration of that from 2010, but it was something I had clearly given some thought to prior. That I find the exact same sentiment in this book from three decades ago speaks to just how much I took this issue to heart.
The second thing that strikes me is that the issue holds up really well. There's some dated cultural references and clothing styles, but it holds up very well overall. Yeah, it's not terribly subtle, but for a stand-alone issue, I don't know that it has the time to afford to be. Were I 14, 15, 16 years old now, I suspect I'd respond to it in much the same way as when I first encountered it. Which speaks very well to the storytelling going on here.
But more importantly, it means that the underlying message holds up as well. That those labels that people ascribe to us can have a self-defeating prophecy. That bigotry is another form of bullying, and can be equally traumatic. People aren't labels. People are people, and if you ascribe ANY traits to them based on some broad classification of race or gender or sexuality or whatever, you are being a bigot and a bully and should be treated accordingly.
You want to know who I am? I'm Sean Kleefeld. That's the only thing that matters. The rest are just labels.
The theme of the X-Men as a stand-in for racism and bigotry was well-trod by then. Looking back, it could be a bit ham-fisted at times, but for pre-teens and teenagers, you tend to need that lack of subtlety to get your message across. That New Mutants story was a little like that.
In the story, a student arrives at a new school and is taunted by all the popular kids. They call him "such a rat-faced, geeky little dweeb" that he must be a "mutie." Which stings more than it might because he was, in fact, a mutant. He's bullied more and, rather than continue to face the ongoing taunts, commits suicide.
The story ended with Kitty Pryde providing a eulogy...Reading that again now, I still get teary-eyed. It was an incredibly powerful statement for me to hear at that time in my life, and I carried that comic around like a totem for months. I read it over and over again, on seemingly every bus ride home from school after yet another day of insults and ostracization. This single comic is largely what got me through high school.
And this is me we're talking about here. White, gisgendered, heterosexual male. I have just about every social priveledge that one can be born with. By all rights, I shouldn't have needed this. I shouldn't have needed to be so deeply touched by the message in this comic. I shouldn't have needed to be told that those insults are nothing compared to what some people endure. I shouldn't have needed to be told that those insults were just labels meant to confine us to a small box.
I pulled this issue out for the first time in decades to write this post. I set the comic aside when I left for college, thinking that I would effectively be able to start over and leave all of that high school bullshit behind. And I've never cracked it since then for fear that it would be far inferior than the importance I put upon it would critically warrant. But I was struck by two things just now in re-reading this issue.
First, that last panel. I didn't consciously remember that as a critical part of the story or even a significant part of Kitty's speech. But I know that for a little over a decade now, I've actively eschewed labels of any kind. I can only find a published version of my declaration of that from 2010, but it was something I had clearly given some thought to prior. That I find the exact same sentiment in this book from three decades ago speaks to just how much I took this issue to heart.
The second thing that strikes me is that the issue holds up really well. There's some dated cultural references and clothing styles, but it holds up very well overall. Yeah, it's not terribly subtle, but for a stand-alone issue, I don't know that it has the time to afford to be. Were I 14, 15, 16 years old now, I suspect I'd respond to it in much the same way as when I first encountered it. Which speaks very well to the storytelling going on here.
But more importantly, it means that the underlying message holds up as well. That those labels that people ascribe to us can have a self-defeating prophecy. That bigotry is another form of bullying, and can be equally traumatic. People aren't labels. People are people, and if you ascribe ANY traits to them based on some broad classification of race or gender or sexuality or whatever, you are being a bigot and a bully and should be treated accordingly.
You want to know who I am? I'm Sean Kleefeld. That's the only thing that matters. The rest are just labels.







