With a name like The Vanishing of Lake Peigneur, I think it'd be easy to assume this is some fantasy book about wizards or aliens or something. It is not. Rather it is a true story, not one passed down for several generations and may have been exaggerated in places, but from an incident that occurred in 1980. Of which we have news accounts of the time. Of which many of those who were involved are still alive and open to interviews. Of which was a large enough event to have numerous official reports drawn up, including the formal paperwork from any number of lawsuits that resulted from Lake Peigneur literally vanishing down what amounted to a giant drain.
Creators
Allan Wolf and Jose Pimienta follow the events of the day, starting from when everyone in the area began work that morning. Although technically using a third-person omniscient narrator, the story is told from the perspective of the lake itself and whatever it saw/heard/felt. So we see what happens to the two local guys just out fishing and the 50-some guys working at the salt mine and the half dozen men stationed on the oil rig and so on. Each of their stories play out more or less simultaneously, which makes for an interesting set of perspectives -- what the miners were seeing and experiencing 1,000 feet underground was radically different than what the fishermen were dealing with. Even though it was the exact same event. So the reader gets a full view of what's happening while most of the characters are acting with an (understandably) extremely short-sighted understanding in the moment.
And even though we never learn the precise cause of everything, we do have a good understanding of what happened once things started going wrong.
I have to admit that I found the dialogue a little off-putting at first. It initially felt overly simplistic, like a young children's book. But as it continued, I realized it felt more like song lyrics. Like a Lake Peigneur graphic novel version of Gordon Lightfoot's The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald. To be clear, it doesn't not hold a specific cadence or rhyme scheme but it has the overall tone of a tragic ballad. (Although considerably less tragic than Lightfoot's song, since no one was killed in the Lake Peigneur incident.)
I think the most frustrating thing for me, reading about this event decades after the fact, isn't the story here -- Wolf and Pimienta do a solid job with the narrative -- but the actual events themselves. What I mean is that we have this absolutely massive, decidedly man-made disaster -- a 3.5 billion gallon lake entirely drained in a matter of hours, taking with it much of the immediately surrounding land and what was on it -- and nature essentially corrected itself in the same day. The whirlpool stopped, the lake filled back up, locals were boating on the water the next day. Everything that mankind had done to cause the devastation in the first place was effectively wiped clean. As traumatizing as it must have been for everyone who lived through event, none of the people actually responsible -- the oil rig and mine owners -- really have to even look at what they did. It was just some numbers they had to write off on a ledger somewhere. There were no real consequences for those people to even see, so they could just keep doing the same type of thing over and over again.
They're only going to be as careful as to not lose any equipment in the future, regardless of what the impact might be to the environment.
But overall, it's a good story and weird piece of history that isn't commonly known. As is noted in the Author's Note at the end, it didn't even get all that much national media coverage at the time because no one died. So it's scarcely known about today. Worth taking a look for that reason alone.
Although the book originally came out in 2025, Candlewick Press only just published The Vanishing of Lake Peigneur in paperback form last month. It retails for $14.99 US and should be available through your favorite bookseller.
The Vanishing of Lake Peigneur Review
By Sean Kleefeld | Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Leave a Comment





0 comments:
Post a Comment