160 million readers sounds spectacular. But its paid-content business is disproportionately carried by roughly 5.9 million paying customers in Korea and Japan.This harkens back to the last time I talked about Webtoons here, back in September. My whole question then was, "Are Webcomics Financially Scalable?" And when I looked at their financials back in March, shortly after they released their annual report, and suggested that they keep trying to hype up their business, but no one seems to be buying into it. When they first listed their stock back in June 2024, they valued the company at around $23 US per share. Within a couple months, it had plummeted to $10 and, with the exception of a brief uptick when they first announced a deal with Disney, has spent all of its time since easily below $15. Frequently below $10.
Basically meaning that pretty much everybody feels Webtoon is worth less than half of what Webtoon has been trying to push. Think of it like this: you're trying to sell an old comic book on eBay for $50, but no one buys it no matter how often you list it. You think it's a great comic and easily worth $50. But no one seems to share that sentiment. You occasionally get someone who makes you an offer of $20 or $25, but never more than that. That's what's going on with Webtoon.
As
I type this, their share price is less than $10 US.
Again, the question is not whether or not webcomics can be popular; they clearly are. And it's not whether or not they can be profitable; there are any number of creators making a living from doing webcomics. The question is one of scale. Can you run webcomics as a business when you've got more than just a couple of creators? The best financial news Webtoon seems to be able to provide right now -- they had their quarterly earnings call a little over a week ago -- is that lost less money than they lost last year. Which, yeah, is an improvement, but not exactly a stellar one.
That Webtoon is financially performing better in Japan and Korea isn't terribly surprising. The key will be discovering what elements of webcomics -- probably some combination of storytelling, genre, and the technology itself -- can be replicated elsewhere and what elements need to be cultivated more uniquely for the particular cultural markets they go into elsewhere.




0 comments:
Post a Comment