Today is the 75th birthday of Dennis the Menace -- that kid in the striped shirt, armed with a slingshot, causing problems for pretty much everyone in the neighborhood, sometimes with his dog as an accomplice. Of course, depending on whether you're reading this in the US or in the UK, you've likely got very different characters in your head at the moment.
If you're a regular reader of this blog, you probably already know that both Hank Ketcham and David Law independently thought up ideas for a character called "Dennis the Menace" -- the rhyming name scheme is relatively obvious -- and, by a wild coincidence, both happened to first see print on the exact same day: March 12, 1951. Despite my deliberate attempt above to frame the characters as virtually identical, they really only share the most superficial elements. Thematically, they come from very different places -- the US version celebrates the wonder and innocence of children who haven't yet learned social conventions and mores, while the UK version shows what happens when a child knows but actively rejects those now learned social conventions and mores. The US Dennis annoys people because his ignorance of ettiquite means he winds up innocently doing and saying things people don't like. He has a lack of empathy because he hasn't learned it yet. The UK Dennis annoys people because he's specifically trying to cause chaos, mostly to alleviate his own boredom in day-to-day routine. His lack of empathy isn't because he hasn't learned it, but because he actively chooses his own immediate interests over others' regardless of the consequences.
What I find particularly fascinating about the coincidence of two characters named Dennis the Menace appearing on the same day on opposite sides of the Atlantic is how they've both been about equally successful in their respective countries of origin. It would be an interesting coincidence if both characters debuted simultaneously, but either one or both was nothing more than a brief splash of interest, falling out of print after a year or two. For as many comics do last a short time like that, nobody would bat an eye and it probably wouldn't be until decades later that some comic archivist happened across the coincidence. But instead both characters have been not only successful to have remained continually in print for 75 years, but they've both been the subject of multiple TV shows and movies, video games, and the like. The UK Dennis was a theme park mascot for a little over a decade, while the US Dennis has had two playgrounds built around him. They've shown up on clothes and lunchboxes and coffee mugs. They've had dolls and figures made of them. Fans have cosplayed as them.
Their successes haven't been precisely parallel, and I'm sure you could quantify which was more "successful" (i.e. which has made more money over time) but that they're both close enough to be commonly understood in the same ballpark is almost as amazing as their debuting on the same day.
The characters will no doubt to continue to evolve over time. Both Ketcham and Law passed away decades ago now, and the characters have had a number of artists and writers working on them since, obviously bringing their own preferences and biases to the table in the process. But that both characters have survived at all with so few (relatively speaking) changes would be really nothing short of astounding even if they had a full year between them.
Happy birthday, Dennis! And happy birthday, Dennis!
If you're a regular reader of this blog, you probably already know that both Hank Ketcham and David Law independently thought up ideas for a character called "Dennis the Menace" -- the rhyming name scheme is relatively obvious -- and, by a wild coincidence, both happened to first see print on the exact same day: March 12, 1951. Despite my deliberate attempt above to frame the characters as virtually identical, they really only share the most superficial elements. Thematically, they come from very different places -- the US version celebrates the wonder and innocence of children who haven't yet learned social conventions and mores, while the UK version shows what happens when a child knows but actively rejects those now learned social conventions and mores. The US Dennis annoys people because his ignorance of ettiquite means he winds up innocently doing and saying things people don't like. He has a lack of empathy because he hasn't learned it yet. The UK Dennis annoys people because he's specifically trying to cause chaos, mostly to alleviate his own boredom in day-to-day routine. His lack of empathy isn't because he hasn't learned it, but because he actively chooses his own immediate interests over others' regardless of the consequences.
What I find particularly fascinating about the coincidence of two characters named Dennis the Menace appearing on the same day on opposite sides of the Atlantic is how they've both been about equally successful in their respective countries of origin. It would be an interesting coincidence if both characters debuted simultaneously, but either one or both was nothing more than a brief splash of interest, falling out of print after a year or two. For as many comics do last a short time like that, nobody would bat an eye and it probably wouldn't be until decades later that some comic archivist happened across the coincidence. But instead both characters have been not only successful to have remained continually in print for 75 years, but they've both been the subject of multiple TV shows and movies, video games, and the like. The UK Dennis was a theme park mascot for a little over a decade, while the US Dennis has had two playgrounds built around him. They've shown up on clothes and lunchboxes and coffee mugs. They've had dolls and figures made of them. Fans have cosplayed as them.
Their successes haven't been precisely parallel, and I'm sure you could quantify which was more "successful" (i.e. which has made more money over time) but that they're both close enough to be commonly understood in the same ballpark is almost as amazing as their debuting on the same day.
The characters will no doubt to continue to evolve over time. Both Ketcham and Law passed away decades ago now, and the characters have had a number of artists and writers working on them since, obviously bringing their own preferences and biases to the table in the process. But that both characters have survived at all with so few (relatively speaking) changes would be really nothing short of astounding even if they had a full year between them.
Happy birthday, Dennis! And happy birthday, Dennis!



























